HYSTERECTOMY: WHAT TO LOOK FOR IN A PRACTITIONER
Friday, May 8th, 2009An essential quality in any health practitioner is good communication skills. He or she should listen carefully to what you have to say and give you a clear explanation of the possible or likely nature of your illness or disease. Together you should discuss the proposed approach to tests, diagnosis and treatment, including what the proposed approach entails; the expected benefits, common side-effects and risks; whether the intervention is conventional or experimental; and who will undertake it. Your practitioner should raise with you, or you should ask about, other options for investigation, diagnosis and treatment. Another important attribute of a practitioner is the ability to convey information in an effective yet sensitive manner and to recognise what you have gone through already and may yet go through. A practitioner who is unable to put him or herself in your shoes is less likely to understand your preferences or needs. If there are language difficulties between you and your practitioner, encourage the doctor to arrange for an interpreter to be present or, if this is not possible, bring someone with you who can translate.
Once a diagnosis has been arrived at, you should be informed of any uncertainties about that, or about the outcome of any treatment proposed. You need to be sure that the outcome expected from the treatment is compatible with what you want from treatment. For example, if you still desire children and you do not have a life-threatening cancer, a hysterectomy is not a sensible first option for you. The doctor may want to discuss the likely consequences if you do not choose to have a proposed treatment. The expected time to recovery and financial costs are matters that you may also need to discuss. In addition, it is particularly important that you satisfy yourself that the doctor is experienced and skilful in the job to be done, and that any significant risk of long-term physical, emotional, social, sexual or other outcome is known to you.
The issue of what constitutes a ‘significant risk’ received lengthy consideration during a recent Australian High Court decision (Rogers v. Whitaker [1992]). The case concerned a woman who was blinded by the treatment she received, a less than one in 1000 chance in her particular case. The presiding judge defined the risks to be discussed by a doctor with his or her patient as those which, in the circumstances of the particular case, a reasonable person in the patient’s position would be likely to attach significance to if warned of the risk.
In practice, some doctors seem to think they should have control over what is discussed. A 1993 study of over 1000 doctors, conducted for Australian federal health authorities, found that 84% considered there were circumstances in which they would be justified in withholding information.14 Some of the reasons given seem questionable at best. About a third of the doctors said they would consider withholding information if they thought a patient might refuse treatment, while between a third and a half would consider withholding information if they regarded the patient as a poor decisionmaker. Only half of the doctors surveyed said they always discussed the risk of death or serious disability where it occurred at least as often as once in every 100 cases. For lower risks of death or disability (one in 1000 was specified) less than a quarter of the doctors said that they always discussed these with patients. On a more hopeful note, another Australian study of doctors found that the most significant changes to medical practice over a recent five year period were ‘taking more time to explain risks’ and ‘spending more time on patient record keeping’.
Before making decisions about treatment, it is a help if your doctor draws a picture of the suggested treatment approach if this is possible (and it certainly is where surgery is involved), and gives you written materials to take home and think about. If you are unsure, ask more questions. If you are still undecided, ask for time to make up your mind. Don’t be hurried. Except in the case of a diagnosed cancer, time is on your side.
If you need to go to a clinic or a hospital for treatment, the practitioner should provide you with clear information about any pre-treatment requirements (such as stopping the Pill a month before major surgery, stopping smoking at least a week beforehand, and refraining from food and drink from the night before a general anaesthetic). You should also be given details of your continuing health care, for example post-treatment check-ups, once you are discharged from a clinic or hospital.
*65\198\4*